What Would YOU Ask Elena Kagan?

Elena Kagan continues to make the rounds on Capitol Hill to lobby for her confirmation this summer. She’s met with several Democrats and some swing Senate Republicans in the days after her nomination. While Kagan lobbies, Senators get a chance to ask her questions before the formal confirmation hearings with the Judiciary Committee. But what if you were a Senator for one day, what question would you ask Elena Kagan?

[redlasso id=”f27a4f93-e5f1-42f8-ab32-e3c8c18e8f3b”]

[redlasso id=”8ccccb40-4396-4106-b6d4-d29230ae5c01″]

Questions or Comments? Feel free to E-Mail Ari , post a comment on this blog, or send a message on Facebook or LinkedIn .


POTUS Nominates Elena Kagan, What Happens Now?

President Obama has nominated Elena Kagan to the Supreme Court. Now comes the “getting to know you” phase, in which Kagan will visit key Senators and answer questions about her background and personal opinions on key legal issues. This process will take several weeks and lead up to Senate Judiciary Committee hearings this summer. I spoke with Michael O’Neill, Professor of Law at George Mason University and the former Senate Judiciary Chief Counsel and Staff Director during the Samuel Alito and John Roberts hearings in 2006. O’Neill told me what happens in the days after the nomination inside the halls of the US Senate.

[redlasso id=”c38d0259-dc10-4baa-b84e-905b89da1bae”]

[redlasso id=”b3dd50e2-6251-43ca-9828-09d8c65729e4″]

PRODUCERS HAT: An A+ producer has plenty of resources and prepares for these events ahead of time. I posted an article about how to prepare and I hope you did! We spoke to Thomas Goldstein, who publishes SCOTUSBlog and is a partner at Akin-Gump (a DC Law firm). He’s very good at analyzing Supreme Court news and he spoke with WTOP’s Dimitri Sotis.
[redlasso id=”b266e638-e0c0-4b8e-87ac-1814eab91d10″]

Questions or Comments? Feel free to E-Mail Ari , post a comment on this blog, or send a message on Facebook or LinkedIn .

A Former Solicitor General Weighs in on Elena Kagan Nomination

President Obama has chosen Elena Kagan as his Supreme Court nominee. If she were to be confirmed, she’d be the fifth former Solicitor General to later join the Court. The list includes Robert H. Jackson, Stanley Forman Reed, William Howard Taft and Thurgood Marshall.

Several experts note that if Mrs. Kagan were to be confirmed, she’d likely have to recuse herself from more than a dozen cases in the fall because of her work as Solicitor General. Thurgood Marshall had to recuse himself from about 57-percent of cases in his first year on the court.

[redlasso id=”89ca2496-c584-46df-ac16-e4f7bd765eba”]

[redlasso id=”ec33ace1-6147-4425-bb7e-cbac0b0395b0″]

PRODUCERS HAT: Del Waters interviews Jeffrey Rosen, GW Law Professor and Legal Affairs Editor at The New Republic. This broke at 10:35pm last night and that’s why an A++ producer knows how to reach his sources at home. I may have woke Jeffrey up, but he was willing to join us and he gave amazing insight!
[redlasso id=”d01c4730-a943-40a1-89cc-dbcefa6e40ee”]

Questions or Comments? Feel free to E-Mail Ari , post a comment on this blog, or send a message on Facebook or LinkedIn .

Are You Prepared for the Next Supreme Court Nomination?

If you aren’t ready, why not? Remember the old Boy Scouts motto: “Always be prepared”. Nothing could be more true for a producer. If you can’t be prepared for what you know is coming, then you’ll be lost when the unexpected hits. And trust me, it will happen!

If the past is any indicator, President Obama will name his nominee around mid-May, so you should begin your homework now.

Who’s on the President’s list? Here’s a list I’ve compiled from several news outlets:

1) Elena Kagan, Solicitor General

2) Judge Diane Wood ot the 7th Circuit Court of Appeals

3) Judge Merrick Garland of the DC Court of Appeals.

4) Stanford Law Professor Pamela Karlan

Those four are considered the frontrunners.  Does that mean you prepare for only these four?  NO!  Like a Professor who provides 8 essay questions and says 4 will show up on the final exam, you could “guess” and prepare for 6.  But, what happens if you’re wrong? The A+ student is ready for all 8 options. The A+ producer is the same.

Here are the other “less likely” names on the list: Janet Napolitano, Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm, Cass Sunstein, Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick.


Very good question. There are several categories of people you can target.

1) Supreme Court Watchers: These people are often either lawyers who argue before the Court frequently. It’s up to you to do the homework, but here’s one freebie: Thomas Goldstein. He’s a Supreme Court specialist at Akin-Gump in Washington DC and he runs SCOTUSBlog.com. He’s a highly sought after guest and he’s always insightful into Supreme Court matters.

2) Constitutional Scholars: These are people who follow constitutional issues, not necessarily the Courts. They comment on the key issues and how someone reads the Constitution. Law school professors often call this “Constitutional Interpretation” and some categories include: Literalism, Normative, Original Intent.

3) Professors of Law: These people teach law, teach the Court and follow current events. Two schools with great resources are Georgetown and Stanford Universities. In fact, Stanford has it’s own Supreme Court Litigation Clinic with several great professors who follow the courts.

4) Think Tanks: Many of them have constitutional law guys. But do your research! Several think-tanks have specific political tints.

5) Journalists: There’s good news-bad news here. Journalists who follow the Court will not give you a partisan analysis, but there will not likely be much analysis either. Reporters don’t state their opinion, they just state the facts. Nonetheless, Joan Biskupic covers the Court for USA Today and Linda Greenhouse at Yale University use to cover it for the New York Times.

6) Former Clerks: Lots of these former clerks are now lawyers and Professors, but I separate them here because every one of these potential nominees have had clerks. Who knows Merrick Garlan or Diane Wood better than a former clerk who worked for them? 


The best resources available come from newspapers, radio and TV. Go into the archives for the Washington Post, New York Times and the Wall Street Journal and see who they quote in Supreme Court articles. You can similiarly go into the archives for CNN, Fox News, NBC, CBS, PBS, ABC. Go to their websites. Or consider Lexis-Nexis. It’s a paid service and it’s not cheap, but you’ll get access to more data than you can handle. If you don’t want to pay, don’t worry. Lexis-Nexis offers free access to TV Transcripts for the major news outlets. Surf around the ‘Net and you’ll find some good stuff. The same applies to radio outlets like CBS, CNN, ABC, and Fox News.   Or, go the library and do some digging. Go back to your college roots.

My home always has a huge stack of newspapers, transcripts and lists piled up. That’s how my Rolodex has 2,500 names and growing!


Three places are the best way to track down phone numbers for any topic: Google, USSearch.com, White Pages. Lets say you want to find me: Ari Ashe. Where is WTOP? Washington D.C. Google it and you find my work number is 202-895-5000. How about where I live? Go to USSearch.com and type my name in. You’ll find me. And then go to the White Pages, type in my name and city. You’ll find me. Not every source will have their number listed, but many do.


Questions or Comments? Feel free to E-Mail Ari , post a comment on this blog, or send a message on Facebook or LinkedIn .